|
Register | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Today's Posts | Search |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Boycott these Calgary Retails (selling sodastream - israeli company)
Home Outfitters
33 Heritage Gate S.E Heritage Town Centre Calgary, AB T2H 3A7 Get Directions Home Outfitters 164, 4916 - 130 Ave. SE Shepard Regional Centre Calgary, AB T2Z 0G4 Get Directions Canadian Tire 5404 Dalton Drive N.W. Calgary, AB T3A 2C3 Phone: 403-288-1100 Get Directions Sears Canada #1-100 Anderson Rd. S. E. Calgary South Centre Calgary, AB T2J 3V1 Get Directions Sears Canada 6455 Macleod Trail South Chinook Centre Calgary, AB T2H 0K4 Get Directions Staples Bay #3 321 - 61st Avenue SW Calgary, AB T2H 2W7 Phone: 403-259-6928 Get Directions Sears Canada 1616-14th Ave. N.W. North Hill Shopping Centre Calgary, AB T2N 1M6 Get Directions Wal-Mart 1110 57Th Ave N E Calgary, AB T2E 9B7 Phone: 403 730 0990 Get Directions London Drugs 3630 Brentwood Road NW Brentwood Village Mall Calgary, AB T2L 1K8 Phone: (403) 571-4933 Get Directions Staples 121, 565 -36th Street N.E. Calgary, AB T2A 6K3 Phone: 403-204-3644 Get Directions Staples 3030 32nd Avenue NE Calgary, AB T1Y 5Y7 Phone: 403-735-6336 Get Directions Staples 5662 Signal Hill Centre Drive SW Calgary, AB T3H 3P8 Phone: 403-217-7070 Get Directions Wal-Mart 100-310 Shawville Blvd S E Calgary, AB T2Y 3S4 Phone: 403 201 5415 Get Directions The Bay 100 Anderson Road S.E. Southcentre Shopping Ctr Calgary, AB T2J 3V1 Get Directions Sears Canada 1600-3800 Memorial Dr. N. E. Marlborough Mall Calgary, AB T2A 2K2 Get Directions London Drugs 4701 - 130th Avenue. SE First Calgary SE Calgary, AB T2Z 4J2 Phone: (403) 571-4964 Get Directions Canadian Tire 4155 126 Avenue SE Calgary, AB T2Z 0A1 Phone: 403-257-4729 Get Directions Home Outfitters 3333 Sunridge Way N.E. Sunridge Way, Spectrum Shopping Center Calgary, AB T1Y 7H5 Get Directions The Bay 2525 36 Street NE Sunridge Mall Calgary, AB T1Y 5S4 Get Directions Myric Electronics Ltd. A13-416 Meridian Road SE Calgary, AB T2A 1X2 Phone: 403-299-0333 Get Directions Home Outfitters 5111 Northland Drive, N.W. Northland Village Mall Calgary, AB T2L 2J8 Get Directions Staples 130 Country Village Road NE, Unit 307 Calgary, AB T3K 6B8 Phone: 403-509-3265 Get Directions London Drugs 3545 - 32nd Avenue NE London Town Square Calgary, AB T1Y 6M6 Phone: (403) 571-4931 Get Directions Canadian Tire 3516 8th Ave. N.E. Calgary, AB T2A 6K5 Phone: 403-248-6400 Get Directions London Drugs 1508 - 8th Street SW Mount Royal Village Calgary, AB T2R 1J9 Phone: (403) 571-4958 Get Directions |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Skip to main content
Home The Electronic Intifada Main menu News & Analysis Action & Activism The Media EI Extra Blogs الانتفاضة الإلكترونية Search form Search You are here Human Rights SodaStream "treats us like slaves," says Palestinian factory worker Stephanie Westbrook The Electronic Intifada Rome 9 May 2013 130509-boycott-sodastream.jpg Sodastream, which exploits Palestinian labor, has been protested by rights activists. (Flickr) A professionally-produced video recently appeared on YouTube, taking the viewer on a carefully-constructed tour of the production facilities for the Israeli company SodaStream, manufacturer of carbonated drink machines. The 8.5-minute video focuses on the firm’s factory located in Mishor Adumim, the industrial zone of the illegal Israeli settlement Maale Adumim in the occupied West Bank, and its Palestinian workers. The underlying message throughout the video is that the company’s settlement factory is a “fantastic sanctuary of co-existence” and, despite being built on stolen Palestinian land, is beneficial to the Palestinian economy and workers. The video was recently shown to M., a Palestinian employee of SodaStream who has worked on the assembly line at Mishor Adumim for a long time and lives under Israeli occupation in the West Bank. M. spoke to The Electronic Intifada on condition of anonymity. His immediate reaction to the blissful setting presented in the video was one of shock. “Lies” “I feel humiliated and I am also disgraced as a Palestinian, as the claims in this video are all lies. We Palestinian workers in this factory always feel like we are enslaved,” M. said. The release of the video coincided with the launch of SodaStream boycott campaigns in the US, considered the company’s most important market. Taking advantage of the company’s major marketing offensive in the US, including a $4 million Super Bowl ad, boycott campaigns succeeded in garnering press coverage exposing SodaStream’s complicity with Israeli violations of international law. M. and his fellow workers were unaware of the boycotts. “They never told us about boycotts at all,” he remarked. Instead the premise for the video presented to the workers was nothing less than a way to maintain their jobs, otherwise at risk due to a lack of orders. M. said that “When they came and told us about the video, they announced that they wanted to market SodaStream globally, with a special presentation to the US, and they wanted to show the work and how it was improving.” M. and his coworkers had been told that the company planned to “let some of the workers go before the end of the year,” but a $500-million order from the US had changed things and a “campaign to support the company’s sales” would save their jobs. The YouTube video is clearly part of SodaStream’s public relations campaign, which lately has focused on the company’s Palestinian workers. In a speech given in early February at an Israel Advocacy Seminar in Johannesburg, Amir Sagie, director of the civil society affairs department for the Israeli foreign ministry, stated, “SodaStream have appointed lobbyists — an initiative that is paying dividends” (“Trends to expect from BDS & how to klap them,” MyShetl, 6 February 2013). According to M., the workers appearing in the video were given instructions on what to say. “I actually saw the company preparation work [for the video]; they were preparing all the workers and telling them what to say and how to say it,” he said. In the video, Sodastream’s chief executive Daniel Birnbaum appears as if he’s a constant presence in the Mishor Adumim factory. M. explained that this is not at all the case. “I have worked here for a long time, and I have never seen him at the factory. This is the first time I see him [in the video]. They have their offices in Israel, and they do not come here,” he said. By M.’s estimates, SodaStream employs 800-850 workers on the factory floor, 90 percent of whom are Palestinians. The only Jewish Israelis doing “hand work” are “new immigrants, as they call them; olim hadashim or the ‘black Jews’ as they describe them.” Only a tiny fraction of the Palestinians employees hold higher level positions and there are none at all in management. “In all of SodaStream, there are only two foremen who are West Bank Palestinians, and they are supervised by two Israeli Arabs,” said M. Discrimination When asked if there was discrimination between black and white Jews, M. replied, “Yes, for sure. You will not [find] white Jews wearing yarmulke [a skull cap] doing the hard work or ‘hand work.’ The supervisors who run the factory are mainly Russian and they are managed mainly by the white Jews, and we are ‘Palestinians,’ only workers.” M. also talked of discriminatory hiring practices, explaining that “most Israelis are hired through the company directly,” while West Bank Palestinians require “a special security permit to be employed.” The settlement factory has an internal security officer who “takes care of applying for the permits from the Israeli authorities.” M. added that Palestinian workers from Jerusalem, along with immigrant workers and African Jews, work through external manpower companies and may be hired after nine months “if they prove to be good workers.” Otherwise, he said, “they are let go.” The recent report from the UN Human Rights Council’s fact-finding mission on Israeli settlements notes that a “stringent system of permits and quotas that determines employment in Israel and the settlements lends itself to abuse by contractors and middlemen.” “Not allowed to pray” The video touts an onsite mosque where SodaStream’s Muslim workers go to pray. M. told a very different story. “A good example that shocked me was the claims [in the video] about the freedom to practice our prayers,” he said. “Those claims are all false. There is a full discrimination against the [Muslim] workers and we are denied our right to practice our religion.” M. noted that the mosque shown in the video “is just the locker room,” and that supervisors had “even hidden the carpets from the workers” in an attempt to prevent them from praying. Restrictions on are especially severe on the assembly line, where most West Bank Palestinians work. M. explained that they are only allowed to pray if prayer times fall “during their lunch break,” otherwise “they are not allowed to pray at all.” This is not the first time SodaStream has put its celebration of multiculturalism on promotional display. In 2009, following extensive negative press in Sweden, the workers’ rights organization Kav LaOved reported that SodaStream organized “a party celebrating the factory’s multicultural makeup: Sudanese, Ethiopian, Russian and Palestinian.” The group noted that “some of the Palestinian workers, who had not registered for the event, were only allowed to participate for one hour, and then returned to work while others continued to celebrate multiculturalism in their name” (“Multiculturalism at the Soda Club factory,” 2 May 2009). While M. confirmed Palestinian workers are currently paid “three or four times the salary we can get at the Palestinian Authority” — not the four to five times more mentioned in the video — this only came about following workers’ struggles and protests in which many lost their jobs, the intervention of Kav LaOved and negative publicity in Europe, as documented by the group Who Profits from the Occupation? in a report on SodaStream (“SodaStream: A case study for corporate activity in illegal Israeli settlements,” January 2011 [PDF]). “From work to bed” However, the same job insecurity and harsh working conditions reported by Who Profits remain. M. described the working week at the factory as “from work to bed,” leaving little free time for anything else. Employees work on a “four-two” system, meaning that they work for four days, 12 hours per day, with two days off — totaling 60 hours of work in a seven-day period. According to the Israeli Hours of Work and Rest Law, a working day “shall not exceed eight working hours” and shift workers “shall not be employed for more than one hour of overtime per day, and that the average for three weeks shall not exceed 45 working hours per week.” The SodaStream factory has two shifts, day and night, and M. explained that workers change shifts every four days with “no day that you leave early.” Requests to leave early are rarely approved. These working conditions apply to both men and women. M. explained that women workers also work night shifts and 12-hour shifts. He also noted that “there is no extra pay for overtime or night shifts,” in violation of the Hours of Work and Rest Law. Making the work day or night even longer, Palestinian workers must allow two additional hours for transportation to and from the Israeli settlement, where they are not allowed to live. “They pick us up at six in the morning or the evening, and we arrive home at least an hour after work. Around 14 hours you are away from home, and there is no time to see our families,” M. explained. One big family? SodaStream’s CEO Daniel Birnbaum has referred to the factory workers as one big family. M. disputed this portrayal, and explained some of the job insecurities Palestinian workers face: “They treat us like slaves. This has happened many times on the assembly line: when a worker is sick and wants to take sick leave, the supervisor will fire him on the second day. They will not even give him warning or send him to human resources, they will immediately fire him.” Birnbaum also claims in the video that SodaStream received no government incentives for its settlement factory. However, all three of the company’s own annual reports filed with the Security and Exchange Commission in the US, including the report for 2012, clearly stated that transfer of their production facilities “to a location outside of the disputed territories” may “limit certain tax benefits” (“United States securities and exchange commission, SodaStream International Ltd.”). M. noted that some production is currently being shifted to a new factory at Alon Tavor in the Galilee, within present-day Israel. “Now they have a new assembly department inside Israel, and [the factory] is getting less work. They are forcing the workers to work less, sometimes only for two or three days a week only, which means less salary.” Those unhappy with just 10 to 12 work days per month “are ‘free to go,’” he added. The rumors at the Mishor Adumim factory are that it will soon close, with all production moving inside Israel. Despite the conditions, M. and others “are hoping that the workers will be able to move and continue working there too.” As M. explained, “All of the workers have no other choice but to work in the settlement factory; we want to feed our children and there are no work opportunities in the Palestinian Authority.” Cover for illegality A recently-published update from Who Profits on SodaStream’s facilities showed that the Alon Tavor site serves as cover for the company’s illegal settlement factory. Who Profits cites an article from the Israeli business publication Globes, in which Birnbaum claimed products sold in countries such as Sweden, Switzerland, Norway, Finland, and France are manufactured at Alon Tavor due to “the sensitivity in these countries to Israeli products manufactured beyond the green line.” However, examining details on production facilities listed in SodaStream’s own annual report for 2012, WhoProfits demonstrated that it would not possible for a complete SodaStream machine to be produced at Alon Tavor. The company has also won a 25-million-shekel ($7 million) government grant for construction of a new plant in the Idan Industrial Zone in the Negev (Naqab), capable of housing all of the company’s production under one roof (“SodaStream wins NIS 25 m grant for Negev plant,” Globes, 4 April 2013). Birnbaum recently threatened to move production to another continent if Israeli government subsidies, such as grants and tax breaks, are reduced. According to SodaStream’s 2012 annual report, its effective tax rate was 1.7 percent for 2012, and 10.9 percent for 2011. The corporate tax rate in Israel is 25 percent (“SodaStream CEO: More Israel investment depends on incentives,” Globes, 24 April 2013). While Birnbaum, beholden to his Nasdaq investors, concentrates on the bottom line, his settlement factory is part of a system described in the United Nations Human Rights Council report on settlements as exerting “a heavy toll on the rights of the Palestinians.” This systematic denial of basic rights outlined in that report creates the conditions that force Palestinians to turn to settlement companies for job opportunities. The report maintains that “the inability for the Palestinian economy to expand and offer opportunities, high unemployment rates and falling wages in the Palestinian labor market, inflation and increasing poverty are factors that drive Palestinians to seek employment in the settlements and in Israel.” In an email to The Electronic Intifada, a spokesperson for Who Profits stated that Israeli settlement companies exploit Palestinian laborers while claiming that the work benefits them. “A business that operates unlawfully cannot demand legitimacy on behalf of the workers and at their expense,” the spokesperson said. Who Profits added that in other cases of exploitative employment, “civil society worldwide rejected employers as legitimate representatives of their workers” and maintained instead that “major corporations and colonial powers be held accountable for their actions.” In 1996, Sodastream made a decision to locate its production facilities in an area under military occupation and has maintained them there ever since. When confronted with this clear violation of international law, the company chose not to address it but rather sought to use its Palestinian workers to deflect attention away from its role in maintaining Israel’s unjust colonial system. What we can do as people of conscience genuinely concerned for Palestinian workers, is to step up boycott, divestment and sanctions campaigns against companies like SodaStream, to ensure we can soon celebrate true multiculturalism, with guarantees of equal rights for all. Stephanie Westbrook is a US citizen based in Rome, Italy. Her articles have been published on Common Dreams, Counterpunch, The Electronic Intifada, In These Times and Z Magazine. Follow her on Twitter @stephinrome. Tags: Sodastream settlements settlement products economy Palestinian Authority Daniel Birnbaum BDS Who Profits Mishor Adumim maale addumim racism unemployment Share on facebookShare on twitterShare on email Share Donate now More like this Amena Saleem SodaStream lies to keep its products on UK shelves 6 March 2013 Activism News Swedish chain kicks out drink machines made in Israeli settlements 29 August 2011 | Stephanie Westbrook Opinion/Editorial Israeli firms shed crocodile tears for Palestinian workers 9 April 2013 | Stephanie Westbrook Amena Saleem's picture Amena Saleem Israel steps up SodaStream marketing in attempt to greenwash Israeli settlement crimes 3 February 2013 Maureen Clare Murphy's picture Maureen Clare Murphy Settlement produce exporter Agrexco set for liquidation 1 September 2011 Latest Articles Opinion/Editorial: Why does US treat ex-prisoners from Ireland and Palestine differently? (12 November 2013) Diaries: Live from Palestine: The Month in Pictures: October 2013 (6 November 2013) Human Rights: US Christian Zionists plan to take over Palestinian university in Israel (6 November 2013) Art, Music & Culture: Late artist inspires new film on Palestinian children's dreams (6 November 2013) Art, Music & Culture: Blumenthal's "Goliath" holds mirror to Israeli society (4 November 2013) Opinion/Editorial: Jewish student receives death threats over Palestine solidarity work (4 November 2013) Human Rights: Palestinian lawyer faces Israeli jail for "organizing demonstrations" (31 October 2013) Business & Economy: Unlicensed banks provide "safety net" to besieged Gaza (29 October 2013) Human Rights: Palestinians in Lebanon vow to continue protests against UN aid cuts (29 October 2013) Human Rights: We'll never forget October 1956 massacre, say Palestinians in Israel (29 October 2013) more Latest blog posts The Electronic Intifada Podcast: 30 percent of vital medicines "at zero supply" in Gaza, says released doctor Tarek Loubani (12 November 2013) Nora Barrows-Friedman: Freed filmmaker John Greyson: Canada must address responsibility in Egypt (12 November 2013) al Bassaleh: Colors: the new-new anti-Semitism (12 November 2013) Lobby Watch: "Doctor" of Israeli spin omits key facts in tour of Scotland (12 November 2013) Rights and Accountability: Prison or death? Egypt coup regime forces grim choice on Palestine refugees (11 November 2013) From the Editors: Yes, John Kerry, there can be a single, democratic state in Palestine (11 November 2013) Lobby Watch: As Ambassador Power praises ADL, Abe Foxman savages John Kerry (10 November 2013) Lobby Watch: Pro-Israel groups keen to revive discredited anti-Semitism definition (10 November 2013) Lobby Watch: Union seeks costs from Israel lobbyist after failed "lawfare" suit (8 November 2013) Lobby Watch: Max Blumenthal's "Goliath" seen as threat at heart of Israel's propaganda machinery (8 November 2013) More Your support helps us tell Palestine’s stories every day. Donate Now News & Analysis Opinion/Editorial Israel Lobby Watch Human Rights Internet & Technology Business & Economy Development Action & Activism Activism News Action Items The Media Journalists in Danger Role of the Media Coverage Trends EI Extra Diaries: Live from Palestine Art, Music & Culture Blogs Activism and BDS Beat al Bassaleh Arts and Culture From the Editors Lobby Watch Media Watch Power Suits Rights and Accountability Nora Barrows-Friedman Steven Salaita Jalal Abukhater Ali Abunimah Ben White Asa Winstanley's blog Benjamin Doherty Nour Joudah Michael Deas Maureen Clare Murphy Writers Jillian Kestler-D'Amours Rami Almeghari Sarah Irving Joe Catron Patrick O. Strickland Eva Bartlett Daryl Meador Charlotte Silver Rod Such Linah Alsaafin Amena Saleem Asa Winstanley Sawsan Khalife' Moe Ali Nayel Max Blumenthal Jonathan Cook Maureen Clare Murphy Budour Youssef Hassan Susan Abulhawa Yousef M. Aljamal Lauren Pyott David Sheen Anne Irfan Yves Engler David Cronin Secondary menu About EI Contact Submit to EI © 2000-2013 electronicIntifada.net |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Human Rights
SodaStream "treats us like slaves," says Palestinian factory worker Stephanie Westbrook The Electronic Intifada Rome 9 May 2013 130509-boycott-sodastream.jpg http://cdn1.electronicintifada.net/s...?itok=weAYW3CF Sodastream, which exploits Palestinian labor, has been protested by rights activists. (Flickr) A professionally-produced video recently appeared on YouTube, taking the viewer on a carefully-constructed tour of the production facilities for the Israeli company SodaStream, manufacturer of carbonated drink machines. The 8.5-minute video focuses on the firm’s factory located in Mishor Adumim, the industrial zone of the illegal Israeli settlement Maale Adumim in the occupied West Bank, and its Palestinian workers. The underlying message throughout the video is that the company’s settlement factory is a “fantastic sanctuary of co-existence” and, despite being built on stolen Palestinian land, is beneficial to the Palestinian economy and workers. The video was recently shown to M., a Palestinian employee of SodaStream who has worked on the assembly line at Mishor Adumim for a long time and lives under Israeli occupation in the West Bank. M. spoke to The Electronic Intifada on condition of anonymity. His immediate reaction to the blissful setting presented in the video was one of shock. “Lies” “I feel humiliated and I am also disgraced as a Palestinian, as the claims in this video are all lies. We Palestinian workers in this factory always feel like we are enslaved,” M. said. The release of the video coincided with the launch of SodaStream boycott campaigns in the US, considered the company’s most important market. Taking advantage of the company’s major marketing offensive in the US, including a $4 million Super Bowl ad, boycott campaigns succeeded in garnering press coverage exposing SodaStream’s complicity with Israeli violations of international law. M. and his fellow workers were unaware of the boycotts. “They never told us about boycotts at all,” he remarked. Instead the premise for the video presented to the workers was nothing less than a way to maintain their jobs, otherwise at risk due to a lack of orders. M. said that “When they came and told us about the video, they announced that they wanted to market SodaStream globally, with a special presentation to the US, and they wanted to show the work and how it was improving.” M. and his coworkers had been told that the company planned to “let some of the workers go before the end of the year,” but a $500-million order from the US had changed things and a “campaign to support the company’s sales” would save their jobs. The YouTube video is clearly part of SodaStream’s public relations campaign, which lately has focused on the company’s Palestinian workers. In a speech given in early February at an Israel Advocacy Seminar in Johannesburg, Amir Sagie, director of the civil society affairs department for the Israeli foreign ministry, stated, “SodaStream have appointed lobbyists — an initiative that is paying dividends” (“Trends to expect from BDS & how to klap them,” MyShetl, 6 February 2013). According to M., the workers appearing in the video were given instructions on what to say. “I actually saw the company preparation work [for the video]; they were preparing all the workers and telling them what to say and how to say it,” he said. In the video, Sodastream’s chief executive Daniel Birnbaum appears as if he’s a constant presence in the Mishor Adumim factory. M. explained that this is not at all the case. “I have worked here for a long time, and I have never seen him at the factory. This is the first time I see him [in the video]. They have their offices in Israel, and they do not come here,” he said. By M.’s estimates, SodaStream employs 800-850 workers on the factory floor, 90 percent of whom are Palestinians. The only Jewish Israelis doing “hand work” are “new immigrants, as they call them; olim hadashim or the ‘black Jews’ as they describe them.” Only a tiny fraction of the Palestinians employees hold higher level positions and there are none at all in management. “In all of SodaStream, there are only two foremen who are West Bank Palestinians, and they are supervised by two Israeli Arabs,” said M. Discrimination When asked if there was discrimination between black and white Jews, M. replied, “Yes, for sure. You will not [find] white Jews wearing yarmulke [a skull cap] doing the hard work or ‘hand work.’ The supervisors who run the factory are mainly Russian and they are managed mainly by the white Jews, and we are ‘Palestinians,’ only workers.” M. also talked of discriminatory hiring practices, explaining that “most Israelis are hired through the company directly,” while West Bank Palestinians require “a special security permit to be employed.” The settlement factory has an internal security officer who “takes care of applying for the permits from the Israeli authorities.” M. added that Palestinian workers from Jerusalem, along with immigrant workers and African Jews, work through external manpower companies and may be hired after nine months “if they prove to be good workers.” Otherwise, he said, “they are let go.” The recent report from the UN Human Rights Council’s fact-finding mission on Israeli settlements notes that a “stringent system of permits and quotas that determines employment in Israel and the settlements lends itself to abuse by contractors and middlemen.” “Not allowed to pray” The video touts an onsite mosque where SodaStream’s Muslim workers go to pray. M. told a very different story. “A good example that shocked me was the claims [in the video] about the freedom to practice our prayers,” he said. “Those claims are all false. There is a full discrimination against the [Muslim] workers and we are denied our right to practice our religion.” M. noted that the mosque shown in the video “is just the locker room,” and that supervisors had “even hidden the carpets from the workers” in an attempt to prevent them from praying. Restrictions on are especially severe on the assembly line, where most West Bank Palestinians work. M. explained that they are only allowed to pray if prayer times fall “during their lunch break,” otherwise “they are not allowed to pray at all.” This is not the first time SodaStream has put its celebration of multiculturalism on promotional display. In 2009, following extensive negative press in Sweden, the workers’ rights organization Kav LaOved reported that SodaStream organized “a party celebrating the factory’s multicultural makeup: Sudanese, Ethiopian, Russian and Palestinian.” The group noted that “some of the Palestinian workers, who had not registered for the event, were only allowed to participate for one hour, and then returned to work while others continued to celebrate multiculturalism in their name” (“Multiculturalism at the Soda Club factory,” 2 May 2009). While M. confirmed Palestinian workers are currently paid “three or four times the salary we can get at the Palestinian Authority” — not the four to five times more mentioned in the video — this only came about following workers’ struggles and protests in which many lost their jobs, the intervention of Kav LaOved and negative publicity in Europe, as documented by the group Who Profits from the Occupation? in a report on SodaStream (“SodaStream: A case study for corporate activity in illegal Israeli settlements,” January 2011 [PDF]). “From work to bed” However, the same job insecurity and harsh working conditions reported by Who Profits remain. M. described the working week at the factory as “from work to bed,” leaving little free time for anything else. Employees work on a “four-two” system, meaning that they work for four days, 12 hours per day, with two days off — totaling 60 hours of work in a seven-day period. According to the Israeli Hours of Work and Rest Law, a working day “shall not exceed eight working hours” and shift workers “shall not be employed for more than one hour of overtime per day, and that the average for three weeks shall not exceed 45 working hours per week.” The SodaStream factory has two shifts, day and night, and M. explained that workers change shifts every four days with “no day that you leave early.” Requests to leave early are rarely approved. These working conditions apply to both men and women. M. explained that women workers also work night shifts and 12-hour shifts. He also noted that “there is no extra pay for overtime or night shifts,” in violation of the Hours of Work and Rest Law. Making the work day or night even longer, Palestinian workers must allow two additional hours for transportation to and from the Israeli settlement, where they are not allowed to live. “They pick us up at six in the morning or the evening, and we arrive home at least an hour after work. Around 14 hours you are away from home, and there is no time to see our families,” M. explained. One big family? SodaStream’s CEO Daniel Birnbaum has referred to the factory workers as one big family. M. disputed this portrayal, and explained some of the job insecurities Palestinian workers face: “They treat us like slaves. This has happened many times on the assembly line: when a worker is sick and wants to take sick leave, the supervisor will fire him on the second day. They will not even give him warning or send him to human resources, they will immediately fire him.” Birnbaum also claims in the video that SodaStream received no government incentives for its settlement factory. However, all three of the company’s own annual reports filed with the Security and Exchange Commission in the US, including the report for 2012, clearly stated that transfer of their production facilities “to a location outside of the disputed territories” may “limit certain tax benefits” (“United States securities and exchange commission, SodaStream International Ltd.”). M. noted that some production is currently being shifted to a new factory at Alon Tavor in the Galilee, within present-day Israel. “Now they have a new assembly department inside Israel, and [the factory] is getting less work. They are forcing the workers to work less, sometimes only for two or three days a week only, which means less salary.” Those unhappy with just 10 to 12 work days per month “are ‘free to go,’” he added. The rumors at the Mishor Adumim factory are that it will soon close, with all production moving inside Israel. Despite the conditions, M. and others “are hoping that the workers will be able to move and continue working there too.” As M. explained, “All of the workers have no other choice but to work in the settlement factory; we want to feed our children and there are no work opportunities in the Palestinian Authority.” Cover for illegality A recently-published update from Who Profits on SodaStream’s facilities showed that the Alon Tavor site serves as cover for the company’s illegal settlement factory. Who Profits cites an article from the Israeli business publication Globes, in which Birnbaum claimed products sold in countries such as Sweden, Switzerland, Norway, Finland, and France are manufactured at Alon Tavor due to “the sensitivity in these countries to Israeli products manufactured beyond the green line.” However, examining details on production facilities listed in SodaStream’s own annual report for 2012, WhoProfits demonstrated that it would not possible for a complete SodaStream machine to be produced at Alon Tavor. The company has also won a 25-million-shekel ($7 million) government grant for construction of a new plant in the Idan Industrial Zone in the Negev (Naqab), capable of housing all of the company’s production under one roof (“SodaStream wins NIS 25 m grant for Negev plant,” Globes, 4 April 2013). Birnbaum recently threatened to move production to another continent if Israeli government subsidies, such as grants and tax breaks, are reduced. According to SodaStream’s 2012 annual report, its effective tax rate was 1.7 percent for 2012, and 10.9 percent for 2011. The corporate tax rate in Israel is 25 percent (“SodaStream CEO: More Israel investment depends on incentives,” Globes, 24 April 2013). While Birnbaum, beholden to his Nasdaq investors, concentrates on the bottom line, his settlement factory is part of a system described in the United Nations Human Rights Council report on settlements as exerting “a heavy toll on the rights of the Palestinians.” This systematic denial of basic rights outlined in that report creates the conditions that force Palestinians to turn to settlement companies for job opportunities. The report maintains that “the inability for the Palestinian economy to expand and offer opportunities, high unemployment rates and falling wages in the Palestinian labor market, inflation and increasing poverty are factors that drive Palestinians to seek employment in the settlements and in Israel.” In an email to The Electronic Intifada, a spokesperson for Who Profits stated that Israeli settlement companies exploit Palestinian laborers while claiming that the work benefits them. “A business that operates unlawfully cannot demand legitimacy on behalf of the workers and at their expense,” the spokesperson said. Who Profits added that in other cases of exploitative employment, “civil society worldwide rejected employers as legitimate representatives of their workers” and maintained instead that “major corporations and colonial powers be held accountable for their actions.” In 1996, Sodastream made a decision to locate its production facilities in an area under military occupation and has maintained them there ever since. When confronted with this clear violation of international law, the company chose not to address it but rather sought to use its Palestinian workers to deflect attention away from its role in maintaining Israel’s unjust colonial system. What we can do as people of conscience genuinely concerned for Palestinian workers, is to step up boycott, divestment and sanctions campaigns against companies like SodaStream, to ensure we can soon celebrate true multiculturalism, with guarantees of equal rights for all. |